The Ultimate Guide to Fundraising in 2025: Everything You Need to Know to Raise Money Successfully

Your fundraising efforts face more competition than ever before. While Americans contributed $557.16 billion to charity in 2023, with individual donors accounting for $374.40 billion of that total, the reality is that $4-7 billion in matching gift funds still goes unclaimed annually.

The numbers tell a story of both opportunity and challenge. Recurring giving has jumped from 46% to 57% of donors, and the average one-time donation now sits at $121. Yet most organizations struggle to capture their fair share of charitable dollars, which continue flowing primarily to religion (27%), human services (14%), education (13%), and health (10%).

Here's exactly what you need to know: successful fundraising in 2025 requires more than asking for money. You need strategic planning, diverse approaches, and genuine donor engagement. The organizations that understand this will thrive, while those that don't will continue fighting over scraps.

This guide covers everything from building winning strategies to implementing methods that actually work. Whether you're competing for those charitable dollars or trying to tap into that unclaimed matching gift pool, the fundamentals remain the same.

Understanding Fundraising in 2025

Three major shifts are reshaping how you'll need to approach fundraising this year. Each presents both obstacles and opportunities for organizations willing to adapt.

What has changed in the fundraising landscape

Federal funding cuts and stock-market volatility have created a perfect storm for nonprofits. Trust in institutions—including nonprofits—has declined dramatically, fundamentally altering donor relationships. However, organizations that adjusted their strategies during the pandemic have benefited from strengthened foundation giving driven by strong market growth. Political developments continue creating uncertainty in philanthropic planning.

The opportunity here is clear: while many organizations struggle with these changes, those that address trust issues head-on and diversify their funding sources will gain significant advantages.

Why fundraising is more competitive than ever

You're competing against approximately 100,000 new organizations that emerge each year, all fighting for the same donor attention. Donor retention statistics reveal troubling patterns, especially among new donors and smaller gift contributors. A Massachusetts Nonprofit Network survey found most organizations expect their financial condition to worsen in the coming year. Donor priorities are shifting toward immediate human needs, often at the expense of other causes.

This increased competition means you can't rely on outdated approaches. Organizations that understand their unique value proposition and communicate it effectively will stand out in this crowded field.

The role of digital and mobile giving

Mobile giving has exploded 205%, with average mobile gifts reaching $79. Digital-first donors prove 48% more valuable than offline counterparts. Monthly recurring gifts now represent 31% of all online fundraising. Email, social media, texting, and crowdfunding have become the primary channels for reaching supporters, particularly younger generations. QR codes and text-to-give options have eliminated friction between donors and their desired impact.

The organizations that embrace mobile-first strategies will capture a disproportionate share of giving, while those that resist will watch opportunities slip away.

Your fundraising strategy for 2025 must account for these realities. The question isn't whether these changes will affect you—it's whether you'll adapt quickly enough to benefit from them.

Building a Fundraising Strategy That Works

Strategic planning separates successful fundraising efforts from failed campaigns. Most organizations jump straight into asking for money without laying the groundwork that actually drives results.

Set clear goals and timelines

SMART goals form the foundation of every effective fundraising plan—Specific, Measurable, Attainable, Relevant, and Time-bound. Start by examining your fundraising data from the past five years to understand what actually worked. This historical analysis helps you set targets that stretch your organization without setting you up for failure.

The data shows a clear pattern: successful fundraising teams run regular campaigns and dedicate specific staff time to fundraising activities. The results speak for themselves—49% of organizations grew their revenue in 2024, while 24% remained flat, and 26% declined. Monthly revenue benchmarks will keep you on track toward your ultimate goal rather than hoping things work out.

Identify your target donor segments

Donor segmentation cuts through the noise of generic outreach. You're categorizing supporters based on shared characteristics, which allows for personalized communication that actually resonates.

The numbers reveal something important: 90% of the largest nonprofits build their funding models around a single dominant revenue source. Meanwhile, donor retention statistics show concerning trends across the board—the average retention rate hovers around 45%, while new donor retention drops to just 20%. Understanding these patterns helps you focus your efforts where they'll have the biggest impact.

Choose the right fundraising model

Select a fundraising model that matches your organization's specific situation:

• Donor engagement funnel: Narrows potential donors to those ready to contribute
• Donor engagement pyramid: Builds connections with supporters ready to elevate their giving
• Donor engagement loop: Establishes ongoing outreach patterns to maintain donor engagement
• Donor engagement network: Identifies potential donors connected through acquaintances

Create a compelling case for support

Your case for support explains why donors should contribute to your cause rather than the thousands of other options competing for their attention. Include clear objectives, specific fundraising goals, connection to mission, problem statement, expected impact, and strong call to action.

Keep it concise—donors should be able to digest the entire message in under five minutes. Complex cases that require extensive explanation typically indicate unclear thinking about your own mission and impact.

Need help structuring your nonprofit's financial strategy? Book a call with our team here, or get your free Financial Fitness Score here.

Fundraising Methods That Actually Work

Your fundraising success depends on choosing the right methods for your donor base. After working with organizations for years, I've seen which approaches consistently deliver results and which ones waste precious resources.

Mobile and digital giving dominate

Mobile optimization isn't negotiable anymore. With 57% of nonprofit website traffic coming from mobile devices and mobile transactions up 50% last year, your donation process needs to work flawlessly on phones. Mobile-responsive donation pages achieve an 8% conversion rate, which beats most traditional methods.

Text-to-give options let supporters donate instantly via SMS. QR codes on print materials and event signage provide immediate access to donation pages. These tools eliminate the friction between donor intent and actual giving.

Peer-to-peer campaigns outperform traditional methods

The data tells a clear story: peer-to-peer fundraising achieves a 39% success rate compared to just 22% for traditional approaches. Even better, 75% of peer-to-peer donors are first-time supporters.

The top 30 peer-to-peer programs raised $1.14 billion in 2024. Walk/run events, ambassador programs, and virtual challenges work particularly well because they remove geographic barriers.

Matching gifts remain underutilized

This represents one of the biggest missed opportunities in fundraising. $4-7 billion in matching funds goes unclaimed annually. When donors know a match is available, 84% are more likely to give, and 1 in 3 will increase their gift size.

Most companies match at 1:1 ratios, though some offer up to 4:1 matches. The submission process takes under five minutes, making this an easy win for doubling donation impact.

Direct mail still works better than email

Despite digital trends, direct mail maintains strong performance. 70% of supporters consider direct mail more personal than digital communications. Compare this to nonprofit emails, which average just a 28.59% open rate.

Product-based fundraising adds revenue streams

Merchandise creates ongoing revenue through branded items like t-shirts and water bottles. Custom online stores work best for nonprofits, offering creative control while minimizing upfront costs.

The key is matching your methods to your donor preferences, not chasing every new trend that emerges.

Donor Engagement and Retention Tactics

Acquiring new donors costs five times more than retaining existing ones—yet most organizations spend their energy chasing new supporters while losing the ones they already have. The problem isn't complicated: poor donor engagement leads to poor retention, which leads to constantly fighting an uphill fundraising battle.

How to thank donors effectively

Most organizations get donor acknowledgment wrong. They send generic thank-you letters weeks after receiving donations, then wonder why people don't give again. Here's what actually works: send personalized thank-you messages within 24-48 hours of receiving donations. Every donor gets recognition regardless of gift size—no exceptions.

Board members should write handwritten notes after each meeting. This isn't busy work; it's relationship building. The most important part? Demonstrate impact by clearly explaining how donations are being used. Thirteen percent of donors stop giving simply because they were never thanked.

Using storytelling to build emotional connection

Statistics don't move people to action—stories do. Nonprofits using storytelling in fundraising efforts achieve a 45% donor retention rate versus just 27% for those who don't. The "identifiable victim effect" explains why donors respond more generously to stories about specific individuals rather than faceless groups.

Effective storytelling connects personal experiences to broader issues, then brings it back to the donor's role in creating change. Don't just tell them what happened—show them how their support makes the difference.

Creating a recurring giving program

Monthly donors are worth their weight in gold. They offer higher retention rates (78%) and stick around for approximately eight years. Recurring givers have nearly doubled their presence, growing 127% from 2018 to 2022.

Make monthly options visible on every donation form. Explain the sustained impact of recurring gifts. Offer exclusive benefits like members-only newsletters or event discounts. Small monthly gifts often exceed what someone might give annually.

Leveraging donor data for personalization

Clean, trusted data is essential for personalization. Segment supporters based on their behaviors, interests, and giving history rather than just recency or gift size. Personalized communications consistently lead to higher retention and donation amounts.

Simple personalization works: "From [donor city] to Africa, your gift is saving lives!" performs better than generic messages. Use what you know about donors to make every communication feel relevant.

Avoiding common donor fatigue mistakes

Donor fatigue happens when you contact supporters only to ask for money. The solution? Offer value through impact updates, educational resources, and genuine engagement opportunities. Show tangible results without always making financial requests.

A year-round communication calendar balances appreciation, updates, and strategic asks. Treat donors like partners in your mission, not ATMs.

Conclusion

Your fundraising success comes down to execution, not just planning. The fundraising landscape has shifted dramatically, but the organizations that adapt strategically will capture more of those charitable dollars while others struggle.

You've seen the data: 57% of donors now give monthly, mobile donations jumped 50%, and $4-7 billion in matching gifts sits unclaimed. The question isn't whether opportunities exist—it's whether you'll act on them.

Start with donor retention. It costs far less than acquisition and directly impacts your bottom line. Thank donors within 24-48 hours, create recurring giving programs, and personalize your communications based on actual donor behavior rather than guesswork.

Mobile optimization isn't optional anymore with 57% of nonprofit traffic coming from mobile devices. Your donation pages need to work seamlessly on phones, or you're losing gifts to technical friction.

Most importantly, stop asking for money without building relationships first. The organizations winning in 2025 understand that fundraising is about connecting passionate supporters with meaningful causes—not just extracting donations.

Pick one strategy from this guide and implement it this week. Whether it's setting up text-to-give options, launching a matching gift campaign, or improving your donor thank-you process, small improvements compound over time.

The resources you need to fulfill your mission are out there. Your job is to create systems that capture them consistently while building genuine relationships with the people who believe in your work.

‍